Steve Carell
Mark Hogancamp / Cap'n Hogie
Falk Hentschel
Captain Topf / Louis
Matt O'Leary
Lieutenant Benz / Carl
Nikolai Witschl
Rudolph / Rudy
Patrick Roccas
Stefan / Stevie
Alexander Lowe
Werner / Vern
Stefanie von Pfetten
Wendy
Neil Jackson
Kurt / Major Meyer
Eric Keenleyside
Larry / Friar
Kate Gajdosik
Jennifer Cook
Conrad Coates
Demaryius Johnson
Veena Sood
Judge Martha J. Harter
Brad Kelly
Ulster County Sheriff
Patrick Sabongui
Ulster County Sheriff
Fraser Aitcheson
Ulster County Sheriff
Jeff Sanca
Ulster County Sheriff
Trevor Jones
Ulster County Sheriff
Adrian Persad
NY Court Security Officer
Natasha Denis
NY Court Security Officer
Sharon Crandall
Defense Lawyer
Gerald Paetz
Defense Lawyer
Jason Glass
Defense Lawyer
Matt Ellis
Man in Adult Video
Matthew Kevin Anderson
Sean
Jocelyne Gaumond
Marathon Runner